What can a nineteenth-century fairy tale teach us about how false information gains credibility?
In 1837, Hans Christian Andersen published The Emperor’s New Clothes, the story of an emperor, two swindlers and a magnificent suit of clothes that didn’t exist (Andersen, 1837/2024).
The swindlers claim their extraordinary fabric is invisible to anyone unfit for their position or hopelessly stupid. Nobody wants to admit they can’t see it. The emperor’s advisers admire the imaginary fabric, the emperor joins in, and eventually an entire town applauds a royal outfit that isn’t there.
It takes a child to point out the obvious.
The interesting part isn’t simply that the emperor was deceived. It’s how the deception became accepted. Each expression of admiration reinforced the impression that there must be something to see.
Nearly two centuries later, the story offers a useful way to think about misinformation and disinformation. False information doesn’t become more accurate when people repeat it. But it can become more convincing.
Misinformation and disinformation are often discussed together, but there’s an important distinction.
Disinformation is false or misleading information deliberately created or shared to deceive. Misinformation is false or misleading information shared without intending to deceive.
The difference lies in intent, which isn’t always easy to establish.
In Andersen’s story, the swindlers knowingly invent the fabric. Their deception is deliberate.
But the people who repeat their claim may not all be doing it for the same reason.
Some are unwilling to admit what they cannot see. Others may simply be following the crowd.
That’s what makes the analogy interesting. A false claim can be repeated by people with different motivations, yet each repetition may contribute to its apparent credibility.
The original deception is only part of the story. What happens afterwards can be just as important.
Psychological research offers one explanation for why repeated information can become persuasive.
The illusory truth effect describes the tendency for repeated statements to be judged as more truthful than unfamiliar ones.
Fazio et al. (2015) found that repetition could increase perceived truth even when participants possessed knowledge that contradicted the repeated statements.
One explanation is familiarity. Repeated information becomes easier to process, and that ease can be mistaken for a sign of truth.
This doesn’t mean everyone believes everything they hear repeatedly. Nor does it establish that the emperor’s advisers genuinely believed in the imaginary clothes.
But it helps explain why familiarity and apparent agreement aren’t reliable substitutes for evidence.
Research is not immune to the effects of repetition and apparent authority.
Greenberg (2009) examined a network of 242 scientific papers and 675 citations concerning a biomedical claim about beta-amyloid protein and a muscle disease.
Of the 10 primary research papers investigating the claim, four supported it while six refuted or weakened it.
However, the four supportive papers received 94% of the 214 citations to this primary research, while the other six received only 6%.
Greenberg also identified cases where tentative hypotheses became established facts through repeated citation, without additional supporting evidence.
The underlying evidence hadn’t become stronger, but selective citation and repetition made the claim appear increasingly well established.
This is a slightly different problem from the emperor’s. Here the cloth exists, but it is described as grander than it is.
Greenberg’s findings don’t establish deliberate deception. They demonstrate how selective citation and repeated interpretation can give a claim more authority than its underlying evidence warrants.
The same concern can arise wherever researchers encounter apparently well-established claims, whether in scholarly publications, institutional reports or other information sources.
Perhaps the most important lesson of The Emperor’s New Clothes isn’t that people can be deceived. It’s that apparent agreement isn’t proof that something is true.
For researchers, this raises questions about the information encountered throughout a research project. Does a widely repeated claim rest on independent evidence? Has contradictory information been overlooked? Has an uncertain finding gradually become presented as fact?
These aren’t reasons to distrust every source. They’re reasons to recognise that credibility depends on evidence, not simply on repetition, reputation or apparent consensus.
In Andersen’s story, the truth was one honest observation away. In research, establishing the truth isn’t always so simple.
But questioning whether the evidence is really there is a good place to start.
Curtin Library offers a range of resources to help you engage critically with information, evaluate evidence and develop your scholarly reading, thinking and writing skills, including:
Andersen, H. C. (2024). The emperor’s new clothes (J. Irons, Trans.). The Hans Christian Andersen Centre, University of Southern Denmark. https://hcandersen.dk/en/vaerker/17_The-Emperors-New-Clothes/ (Original work published 1837)
Fazio, L. K., Brashier, N. M., Payne, B. K., & Marsh, E. J. (2015). Knowledge does not protect against illusory truth. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 144(5), 993–1002. https://doi.org/10.1037/xge0000098
Greenberg, S. A. (2009). How citation distortions create unfounded authority: Analysis of a citation network. BMJ, 339, Article b2680. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.b2680
Please make any anonymous comments/ feedback, or suggestions for further posts at this link. If you would like to get in touch or write a post for the Ideas Hub blog, please email karen.miller@curtin.edu.au. Contributions from HDR students are welcome!
Photo by Chuck Pang on Unsplash